Ghost Face - We know he was wearing a mask, but was there anything else identifying about the killer? ...The eyes... the eyes!!!!
Guy Fawkes - Remember, remember, the 5th of... holy shit! Look at those eyes!
Rockstar - This mask had nothing scary about it, but with Buscemi eyes it's somehow the scariest one.
Frankenstein - Using Buscemi's eyes won't get Frankenstein's monster any more friends.
Red Devil - The Buscemi eyes actually turn this one into a pretty good Willem Dafoe mask.
If you think about it, a tree growing eyes on one of it's limb stumps is really terrifying.
Erika's bum really caught the eye of judges because it was the biggest at 42 inches wide!